Choosing between Zerodha and Shoonya can be a game changer for Indian traders. Zerodha, recognized for its diverse investment alternatives and solid reputation, has long been a popular choice. In contrast, Shoonya, a pioneer in zero-commission trading, provides a daring alternative with its revolutionary cost structure.
As we examine these two brokers, we’ll see which one offers the best value for your trading needs. Dive in and explore if Shoonya’s no-fee strategy outperforms Zerodha’s extensive services.
Open an account with Angel One– Click here
Zerodha
In India, Zerodha is a prominent and highly regarded stockbroker that leads the financial services industry. It is the most popular brokerage firm in the country for its size and reputation, which offers an online flat fee discount brokerage model.
For instance, Zerodha encompasses a wide range of investment options such as Equity, Currency, Commodity, IPOs, Futures & Options, Bonds, Government Securities and Direct Mutual Funds. Besides serving a diverse trading community through its robust platform it is sought by individual as well as institutional investors.
Shoonya
Shoonya pioneered by Finvasia is one of the first discount brokers to revolutionize India’s trading culture. Shoonya which went live in 2013 prides itself with commission-free trading across all market segments and exchanges in India.
This innovation has made Shoonya become a game changer in Indian financial markets; thus setting a new standard for cost-effective trading solutions available within the same geographies. Furthermore, Shoonya wants to grant traders with more accessible or cheaper trade experience through its zero-commission model.
Details
|
Feature |
Zerodha |
Shoonya by Finvasia |
|
Downloads |
Over 10 million |
Over 500,000 |
|
Account Opening Charges |
₹200 |
0 |
|
Annual Maintenance Charges (AMC) |
₹100 (no charges if the holding value is less than Rs.50,000.) |
0 |
Brokerage Charges
|
Type of Trade |
Zerodha |
Shoonya by Finvasia |
|
Delivery |
No brokerage |
No brokerage |
|
Intraday |
₹20 per executed order or 0.03% (whichever is lower) |
No brokerage |
|
Futures |
₹20 per executed order or 0.03% (whichever is lower) |
No brokerage |
|
Options |
₹20 per executed order |
No brokerage |
Other Charges
|
Additional Charges |
Zerodha |
Shoonya by Finvasia |
|
Auto Square-off Penalty |
₹50 + GST per order |
None |
|
Call and Trade |
₹50 + GST per order |
None |
|
DP Charges |
₹13.50 per debit |
₹0 |
Analysis
Cost Efficiency
Shoonya by Finvasia is particularly notable for its zero-brokerage model whereby they do not charge for delivery, intraday, futures, and options trades. It is highly beneficial to active traders or people looking forward to minimizing their transaction costs. Conversely, Zerodha has the lowest brokerage fees but offers competitive rates and a wider customer base that may indicate a strong and well-established platform.
Account Opening and Maintenance
Shoonya has a more desirable alternative for those who do not want to pay upfront or annual maintenance charges. Nonetheless, Zerodha will charge you when opening an account or maintaining it on a yearly basis hence this could be essential for one who wants to save on initial cost.
Open an account with Upstox– Click here
Additional Charges
There are several other charges that Shoonya excludes such as auto-square off penalties, call & trade charges and DP charges among others thus reducing overall trading costs further. On the other hand, Zerodha’s incremental costs are relatively minimal although these may accumulate for frequent traders.
App Rating and Performance
Zerodha is rated higher than Shoonya in app rating although it has not had as many performance complaints. This can be a significant limitation for frequent traders who rely on the ability of their platforms to run smoothly and respond in real time.
Customer Care Service
Another crucial aspect is customer service. Shoonya’s chat support noted for being fast and knowledgeable when called upon for help. However, Zerodha provides otherwise with an excellent call feature that directly helps traders whenever they need assistance right away.
Complaint Ratio
On both NSE and BSE, Zerodha has far less complaint ratio compared to Shoonya. A lower complaint ratio relates to greater satisfaction among customers as well as fewer operational issues thereby suggesting that Zerodha renders more reliable services which are user friendly.
Advanced Order Types
Zerodha offers its clients an array of advanced order types such as cover orders, bracket orders, and basket orders among others. These advanced order types are vital for smartly trading professional investors who trade using difficult strategies. However, shoonya doesn’t have advanced orders in some segments like options and currency commodities
Conclusion
Ultimately, whether you choose Shoonya or Zerodha depends on your individual trading requirements and preferences. If you value cost savings as well as lower rates then it could be better going with Shoonya. While if you consider having a well-developed platform with wide User Base which asks additional money for features available from other platforms too; then probably consider Zerodha.
If you found this post useful, please comment “useful”. And I request you to Please share this post on Facebook/WhatsApp with those who need this.
